A quick bit beforehand:
This entry is moreso directed towards my Christian reader(s). If you’re not a Christian, you are by all means welcome to read it, although I cannot say it is really written for you. Also, it’s a bit on the serious side so if you’re looking for something funny… well, you’re probably in the wrong place to begin with, but if you’re looking for something funnier, check back with me in a few weeks.
-
-
So.
You’ve probably heard of this guy Rob Bell. You’ve probably heard of this book he wrote called Love Wins. You’ve probably heard he’s some sort of heretic.
If you haven’t, here’s a quick video for you to watch
-
-
Before the book even came out, Love Wins was met by massive disapproval from prominent Christian figures (John Piper, Mark Driscoll, etc.) causing a bit of controversy. Bell was eventually asked to appear on several morning talk shows, news segments, and even had a story in Time Magazine. Even those outside the Christian community were familiar with this… Rob Bell fellow.
-
-
Well.
The book came out, and some people read it. (including me.)
-
-
Another person who read it was this guy.

-
-
You’ve probably heard of Francis Chan. (Pictured above). After Rob Bell’s book came out, he decided to also write a book regarding the topic of hell. It’s called Erasing Hell.
-
-
Here’s a video for this one.
This book also came out.
And some people read it. (including me.)
So, let’s talk a bit about them.
-
-
Love Wins
This book is incredibly provocative, and I mean that in the purest sense. It simply provokes discussion. I had a 2 hour conversation with my small group before we even read it. It will challenge your views on heaven, hell, God, and justice. If you haven’t read it, I encourage you to do so. If you refuse to read it because you’ve heard Rob Bell’s a false prophet and have already decided on your views of heaven, hell, God, and justice, I may go so far as to say you’re a little narrow minded.
-
-
I would like to think that God is not offended by our attempts to discover truth. To paraphrase Rob Bell, I think God can handle a few questions and discussions, particularly regarding a topic as significant as eternal destiny.
-
-
The book itself basically asks a lot of questions. In fact, Rob Bell actually never explicitly states that he subscribes to the view of universalism, or that everyone goes to heaven (and therefore there is no eternal hell.) To me, the book is actually more of an attack on Calvinism and conservative doctrine than anything else. (Which might be why it’s made so many people angry.)
-
-
Criticism
Some (perhaps many) of Rob Bell’s proposals are a little far fetched. Although they are proposals and not claims (huge difference), they are potentially dangerous and misleading. I would not recommend this book for anyone who is new to Christianity, or ready to believe anything that’s written on paper.
-
-
My Favorite Part of This Book
Rob Bell revisits the story of the Prodigal Son (Luke 15: 11-32) and talks about how completely enraged the older brother was that his younger brother is welcomed back by his father. He goes on to conclude that sometimes, we’re a lot like that older brother. We actually don’t want to see those we view as lost or broken welcomed home by God. We’d rather see them burn in hell. We rejoice in the thought that one day, we will be rewarded, and others will be punished.
-
-
——What? That’s not you? There’s no way humans could be that cruel? Especially Christians?
This is how Americans reacted to the news Osama Bin Ladin had been killed.
Regardless of our opinions, the fact is, a bunch of people celebrated another’s death.
-
-
Or how bout when you hear about the “sinners” going out and having so much fun on the weekends? Don’t you get a little bit envious? A little jealous? Do you ever take restitution in the fact that one day, they’ll be punished, and you’ll get your reward for being good?
We are a lot more like that older brother than we’d like to admit.
-
-
Erasing Hell
This book is also very good. It uses a nice combination of Chan’s voice with Biblical interpretation from co-author Preston Sprinkle. Overall, it argues for a more traditional view of hell than that of Love Wins. I encourage you to read it. To my knowledge, not too many people are outraged by this one.
-
-
Criticism
The book’s back cover reads “This is not a book about who is saying what. It’s a book about what God says.”
Yet, within the first chapter, Francis Chan refers to Rob Bell too frequently for my tastes. (And almost always negatively.). In fact, 6 of his 25 footnotes from the chapter reference Bell. What’s even worse is he admittedly twists Bell’s words to tie him to universalism.
-
-
For instance, Chan writes, “Bell suggests that every single person will embrace Jesus- if not in this life, then certainly in the next.” [essentially calling Bell a universalist.] (Erasing Hell pg 24.)
-
-
In his footnotes, Chan admits, “To be fair, he is not explicitly arguing for this position but listing it as a valid view that would help explain a lot of the tension that we feel when thinking about the hard realities of hell.” (Erasing Hell pg 40.)
-
-
My question is why?
Why do we need to attempt to pick Rob Bell’s book apart?
If this is a book about what God says, what does it matter what Rob Bell says?
-
-
Francis’ video so heavily emphasizes humility, but he pretty blatantly attempts to deconstruct Love Wins piece by piece. At times, the tone of Chan’s book reminds me of an argument I’d find in the comments section of a youtube video.
You know, something along the lines of…
-
-
“xxRealPlaya64-
You say “The sky is blue” but wut about night time?
Idiot.”
-Chozen1xx83
-
-
My Favorite Part of This Book
The opening. I’ll let you read it for yourself.
“If you are excited to read this book, you have issues.
Do you understand the weight of what we are about to consider? We are exploring the possibility that you and I may end up being tormented in hell. Excited would be the wrong term to use here. Necessary would be more fitting.” (Erasing Hell pg 13.)
-
-
I loved this because it punched me right in the face.
I was super excited to read this book! As soon as I found out about it, I bought it as soon as possible and rushed home to crack it open.
-
-
I was definitely humbled on the first page.
And that’s really what I love most about the book as well. For the most part, Francis does do a great job of approaching the subject with humility and compassion.
-
-
Pride
Here’s the point.
-
-
I can only say I’ve learned one thing for sure after all this reading and all of the controversy surrounding the topic.
-
-
Humans are so prideful.
-
-
And Christians may be some of the worst.
-
-
Is there anything more ridiculous than spiritual arrogance?
Is there anything more blatantly repulsive?
(Seriously, think of the Pharisees.)
-
-
You know what I’m talking about. You walk into a church or a small group. You size everyone up.
-
-
“I wonder if they pray as hard as me. Or fast as much. Wonder if they care about sex-trafficking like I do. I wonder if they’ve read Bonhoeffer or Macarthur like I have. Wonder if they can quote scripture like I can, or are as free during worship as I am. Doubt it.”
-
-
The thing that struck me most about Francis’ video was the segment where he likens theological debate to two pieces of clay trying to describe the potter to each other.
It’s so true, isn’t it?
We all think we’re experts, that we’ve got Bible verses or personal revelations to back ourselves up.
-
-
-
Or what about in general?
You think you’re better. You’re more generous, talented, or smart.
Who are you compared to God?
-
-
Isn’t it kind of like comparing two specs of dust? Do we as humans compare dust and say “Well, look at this dust. So much better looking than this other dust here.”
-
-
-
How full of it are we?
How completely pompous is it to believe you are better than someone? Or know better than them?
-
-
Conclusion
I know some of you may be wondering-
Wait, so do you believe in Hell or not?
-
-
I don’t even know, to tell you the truth.
I believe God’s ways are infinitely higher than mine, and that justice is whatever He says it is.
-
-
I will say this though.
The belief that one group will go to heaven and another will go to eternal hell… That makes sense to me. That sounds like something I would do, punish people that rejected me no matter how hard I tried, even after I died for them.
-
-
Because I am prideful, and I’m a stupid human.
And I take pure, uninhibited joy in the fact that God is not like me.